Some Women With Heart Problems Benefit From Cardiac Procedure
Monday, August 18th, 2008
From Bloomberg.com
Women who have had a heart attack benefit from surgery to clear their arteries, though the procedure may harm those with less advanced heart disease, researchers found.
The study, along with earlier research, show that all men with heart attacks or less serious chest pain benefit from the procedure that finds and removes fatty plaque from the arteries. The report in tomorrow’s Journal of the American Medical Association suggests doctors need to be more careful with their female patients when deciding who should get the invasive treatment.
The research, the largest to look at who benefits from the procedure by gender, supports updated guidelines from the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association that recommends doctors treat women who have chest pain with heart medicines rather than the surgery. Future studies need to determine why lower-risk women with unstable heart disease may have different results after routine cardiac catheterization, lead author Michelle O’Donoghue said.
“There’s a tremendous need to better understand gender differences in cardiac care,” said O’Donoghue, a researcher at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston and a cardiologist at Massachusetts General Hospital, in a statement today. “Heart disease continues to be the No. 1 killer in women and yet women remain underrepresented in clinical trials.”
Heart Disease Statistics
One in three women have some form of heart disease and women represent almost 53 percent of all deaths from the condition, according to the American Heart Association. The number of women who die from the disease has exceeded men since 1984.
The researchers looked at eight studies covering 3,075 women and 7,075 men who had suffered a heart attack or chest pain and received a surgical procedure or medicine.
The study found that high-risk women with signs and symptoms of a heart attack had a 33 percent reduced risk of dying, having another heart attack or being re-hospitalized with acute coronary syndrome if they underwent artery-clearing surgery before leaving the hospital compared with those patients given therapy of primarily medicine. Acute coronary syndrome is chest pain and other symptoms that occur when the heart doesn’t get enough blood.
In contrast, lower risk women with a type of chest pain called unstable angina, also known as a near heart attack, didn’t appear to benefit from the procedure. The women had a 35 percent greater chance of dying or having a heart attack than those given primarily medicines, a finding that wasn’t statistically significant, the study said.
More Questions
Researchers are unsure why women may have different outcomes than men following the treatment. O’Donoghue said in an interview today that women may be more likely then men to have pre-existing medical conditions such as high blood pressure and diabetes that could put them at higher risk following the procedure. Women also are at higher risk of bleeding, which is associated with worse outcomes.
Women may be more likely as well to have blockages in the tiniest blood vessels of the heart that can’t be seen easily or fixed by cardiac catheterization, she said.
Based on the study findings, the researchers recommend that men and high-risk women with signs and symptoms of a heart attack undergo cardiac catheterization before leaving the hospital. Lower-risk women without evidence of a heart attack should be treated primarily with medicines and undergo the invasive procedure only if they have ongoing chest pain or an abnormal stress test, O’Donoghue said.
From Bloomberg.com
Women who have had a heart attack benefit from surgery to clear their arteries, though the procedure may harm those with less advanced heart disease, researchers found.
The study, along with earlier research, show that all men with heart attacks or less serious chest pain benefit from the procedure that finds and removes fatty plaque from the arteries. The report in tomorrow’s Journal of the American Medical Association suggests doctors need to be more careful with their female patients when deciding who should get the invasive treatment.
The research, the largest to look at who benefits from the procedure by gender, supports updated guidelines from the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association that recommends doctors treat women who have chest pain with heart medicines rather than the surgery. Future studies need to determine why lower-risk women with unstable heart disease may have different results after routine cardiac catheterization, lead author Michelle O’Donoghue said.
“There’s a tremendous need to better understand gender differences in cardiac care,” said O’Donoghue, a researcher at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston and a cardiologist at Massachusetts General Hospital, in a statement today. “Heart disease continues to be the No. 1 killer in women and yet women remain underrepresented in clinical trials.”
Heart Disease Statistics
One in three women have some form of heart disease and women represent almost 53 percent of all deaths from the condition, according to the American Heart Association. The number of women who die from the disease has exceeded men since 1984.
The researchers looked at eight studies covering 3,075 women and 7,075 men who had suffered a heart attack or chest pain and received a surgical procedure or medicine.
The study found that high-risk women with signs and symptoms of a heart attack had a 33 percent reduced risk of dying, having another heart attack or being re-hospitalized with acute coronary syndrome if they underwent artery-clearing surgery before leaving the hospital compared with those patients given therapy of primarily medicine. Acute coronary syndrome is chest pain and other symptoms that occur when the heart doesn’t get enough blood.
In contrast, lower risk women with a type of chest pain called unstable angina, also known as a near heart attack, didn’t appear to benefit from the procedure. The women had a 35 percent greater chance of dying or having a heart attack than those given primarily medicines, a finding that wasn’t statistically significant, the study said.
More Questions
Researchers are unsure why women may have different outcomes than men following the treatment. O’Donoghue said in an interview today that women may be more likely then men to have pre-existing medical conditions such as high blood pressure and diabetes that could put them at higher risk following the procedure. Women also are at higher risk of bleeding, which is associated with worse outcomes.
Women may be more likely as well to have blockages in the tiniest blood vessels of the heart that can’t be seen easily or fixed by cardiac catheterization, she said.
Based on the study findings, the researchers recommend that men and high-risk women with signs and symptoms of a heart attack undergo cardiac catheterization before leaving the hospital. Lower-risk women without evidence of a heart attack should be treated primarily with medicines and undergo the invasive procedure only if they have ongoing chest pain or an abnormal stress test, O’Donoghue said.
|
|
Renegade
Raise a Smarter Child by Kindergarten
The Better Brain Book